Any news

Released today at 1am. I can't believe I got it. E/E E/VG E/E. It was a great experience just learning how to write a proper research proposal. Apply!

2nd year postbac E/E E/E E/E

E/VG, E/E, E/E. Senior undergraduate.

E/VG E/VG VG/VG. I got an honorable mention which is nice, but sad I didn't get the award. Congrats to everyone who did!

VG/VG, VG/VG, G/G The first two reviewers were very kind, mentioned that I had a strong background, though didn't offer much in the way of improving my application next time. Third reviewer took issue with specific parts of my methodology as well as significance of project. Senior undergrad.

VG/E, E/E, E/E. Second year grad student rejected once when I applied senior year of my undergrad. Very excited!

E/E, E/G, E/E Returning to grad school after doing some work in the industry.

Reasonable and expected. Based on the feedback, it sounds like my application was good overall (although, I got conflicting feedback on my Broader Impacts section). Imperfects aside, the real deal-breaker for them was my lack of research experience. Undergrad. Next year, hopefully!

Honorable mention. E/E VG/VG VG/VG

Wow...still unbelievable. Postbac at the NIH, third gap year. E/E, VG/VG, E/E

Honorable Mention. G/G, VG/Excellent, VG/Fair. Senior in college. Comments were very helpful. Will apply next year!

Has anyone been rejected without review by NSF?

Honorable mention. VG/VG E/VG E/VG. Applied as a post-bac. Will reapply as a grad student.

VG/E E/E E/E - Post-Bac

E/VG, E/VG, E/E - 2nd year grad student

Just found out and I am so excited! I will update this post once I learn how I scored on the application components. I have my MA already and this was the last year I was eligible to apply.

Still shocked. Applied as a postbac with 3+ years of research experience